I just finished watching The Colbert Report, the guest on which was Meghan McCain, the daughter of John McCain. I have to admit that before I saw a previous appearance by her on The Rachel Maddow Show, I didn’t know much about her. I was impressed by her appearance there, and was equally impressed by her appearance on TCR.
I’m not a Republican, which I think is fairly obvious, but whenever I hear about or listen to reasonable, rational Republicans like Meghan McCain, I’m always deliriously happy. At heart, I’m a dork, and I just love discussion. It almost doesn’t matter what we’re discussing; it’s probably going to be interesting to me. In politics, though, it’s so hard to have a thoughtful, productive discussion, because 90% of the time it turns into a screaming match in a matter of minutes. I get why this is so sometimes. I freely admit that there is a topic which I could not discuss academically if my life depended on it (gay marriage, for the record) because it is too personal, and detaching myself is impossible. That said, when so much of the political world is bogged down by ideologues who would rather call each other names than talk about things like the adults they supposedly are–theater gets more ratings that substance, after all!–it’s really nice to see someone out there and think, You know, we agree on almost nothing, but they are totally someone with whom I could have a frank, interesting conversation. It’s good to know that there’s still hope, and that a discussion of politics isn’t always guaranteed to turn into chaos.
After all, I know it’s true in my day to day life, as my brother is a Republican with whom I have had a great many debates, as is my absolute favorite teacher, who is one of the most intelligent and thoughtful people I have ever met, and we’ve always been able to talk rationally. I think we can do this because of this strange thing that I believe is called something like “common decency” and I wish it was reflected much more in the mainstream media and blogosphere. Wouldn’t it be something if everyone could say, “I have different ideas about how the government should run than you do; allow me to explain,” instead of calling them fascists, or communists, or terrorists, or people who hate America, or just plain saying they’re assholes?
I know; I’m a dreamer. But with rational people starting to show up in the mainstream (finally!), I just can’t help but hope.